Don Giovanni

Italian restaurant serving the best brick oven pizza in town. Feeding hungry New Yorkers for over 25 years. Midtown: 358 West 44 St. Chelsea: 214 10th Ave.

7 / 10
168
ratings
Address

358 W 44th St (Btw 8th & 9th Ave.) New York , NY 10036 United States

Reservations Yes
Credit Cards Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails

Comments / 51


Keywords:

seamlessweb Chicken Marsala wine big portions chicken parmigiana happy hour good for groups casual Mediterranean salad sangria desserts dinner carafes lunch quick service theaters avocado city liquor performances
Eden Pascual Arce

The chicken Marsala is the best I've ever tasted. The Marsala is exactly the way it should be - light with a hint of wine , not heavy brown gravy passed as Marsala .

Andres Ripoll

You can't go wrong with any of the chicken/veal dishes, they all come with pasta and blend in with the flavor of the sauce, absolutely delicious. Chicken parmigiana , chicken marsala are my favourites.

Will Cutrone

Chicken Parm is good, not great, but is served in just the right portion with pasta . The garlic knots are amazing, and the environment is warm, jovial, and casual .

Staci Stevens

Awesome, quick service . Good food! Very warm, welcoming restaurant off Times Square. Excellent pizza and Penne Vodka . Kid friendly .

Holiday

Solid Italian American fare , does not disappoint. More local theater crowd than tourist . Loved the pizza , gnocchi and Mediterranean salad .

Baturalp

Great happy hour deals ! Lots of sunlight and spacious seating area. Pasta was tasty but not top of the line .

Michael H

I had the best shrimp avocado bruschetta to start and the gnocchi was incredible...very fresh and tasty!

Chloe Arnold

Everything is great! Also the location for the first comedy club . See the gold sign with all the performers names on brick wall near window- incredible!

Jessica Doby

Best pasta and pizza around Times Square, make sure you try NY Pizza at least once when you're in NY!

lee johnson

Had a wonderful meal, wine was reasonable and weather was nice enough to be served outside. Great atmosphere.

Angélica Ponce

Relax spot , tasty food, good prices!

H

Great food at great prices! Very generous portion sizes too.

Douglas Elliott

Ordered a pepperoni pizza . First received a garlic . Replaced with a mangled pepperoni . Ludicrous !

Brigid M.

The pasta and pizza are great with a half carafe is wine ! Good spot

Rachel

Excellent pizza and Italian food . Close to the theaters !

Jacob Forster

The rustica pizza was great! Generous portions for the price!

Genny

Best Italian in the area! Classic pasta and meatballs

Randi LaFerney

Have them make you a plate of Angel Hair Pasta with Porcini mushrooms ! Scrumptious!

Summer Izkovich

You can never go wrong with the servers and the food????????????

Melanie

Best Italian food in the city .........generous portions . Excellent sangria !

Jodi Dorfman-Siegel

Always love the Rigatoni Special .

Vicki Neidigh

So great! Long day. Perfect pasta , reasonable prices.

drew tarvin

A convenient spot for some good Italian food .

Liz Mack

Both clam pizzas are terrific!

Anna Vargas

Wouldn't recommend the garlic knots (a pile of garlic next to bread knots ). The Hawaiian pizza on the other hand is great! Cash only .

Dane Yankowich

Food was mediocre. Service was awful…stood waiting @ the door for 20 minutes before being acknowledged. Took over an hour to receive a simple salad after ordering, then had to ask 3x to get the check.

Wendy Magerowski

Love the pizzas . Perfect dinner before a show!

Hashem Karim

Rigontina medici is awsooome

Tiffany

Calamari now at both locations! Awesome!

Jelani

Very large portions , and the service is good here

Justin JT

The pizza tastes like paradise

Jackie Chan

I don't have an Italian grandma to compare meatballs to, but if I did and she made them like these, I'd be over every Sunday!

Roman Canas

Ask for a 5 percent discount when you pay in cash

Dale Church

Staff was great Bruschetta was less than mediocre. Meat sauce average, and a bit runny, and the ziti was overcooked. Wouldn't come back for pasta , though I guess I should try the pizza .

Jeff Schonfeld

The Toasted Almond is spot on!

Don Giovanni

Order online with us on SeamlessWeb , GrubHub, Campusfood, and AllMenus!

Jeffrey Anderson

The stuffed shells with mozzarella and meat sauce is excellent.

Adam Wilson

Get the Rigatoni Special . Holy crap, this stuff is good.

Douglas Elliott

It is ice cold too!

Wigbar.com Isaac

And don't leave a wig there. It will get thrown out! But worth it for the knots

Zeb Holt

Chicken Marsala . Amazing. Dip the bread in sauce FTW.

K

Reasonably priced, tasty pasta

Nicholas R

Eating in is cash only , but order on SeamlessWeb if you wanna use a card.

Abel Gregory

Get Anda as a waitress ! Shes awesome!

Jamie Maloney

Large bland portions

Mary E

Didn't really like the waitress ... she took her time and we had to sort everything ourselves. The salmon was great tho!

Diane Chang

Large portions .

Anna Pakman

Don't pay with a credit card if you don't like spending hours w. your credit provider's fraud department figuring out why there are $3K worth of charges from a CVS in Queens on your card.

İnanç

Make own your pizza !

Dia Haykal

The decoration is nice but the food is average.

Similar places nearby :

7.9
Italian
Bocca Di Bacco

Meatballs, app and a few good lamb choices. Large bar and quiet seating in back. Ideal before or after a Broadway show. - Robert S

8.3
Italian
Tavola

Pappardelle with mushroom & ragu is amazing! - Ecenaz Özcengiz

7.3
Italian
Cara Mia

Service was great, the food was good. Started with mixed green salad followed by the rigatoni siciliana. Nice wine selection as well. Finished with tiramisu and an espresso shot. Went home happy - Nak Brat

8.9
Bakery
Schmackary's

Try their gluten free cookies: green tea and sweet corn are delicious - Cheryl M

9.2
Theater
St. James Theatre

Excellent show. A must see....even if you are not a Green Day fan. Very accurate portrayal of misguided youth. - Melissa C

8.4
Plaza
Times Square

Nice shopping area, big screens, enjoy walking - Mazen Jamjoom