Frosty Bar is proud to serve island visitors and locals for more than 60 years. Whether you’re hungry for a pizza, thirsty for a cold beer, or looking for the best breakfast on Put-in-Bay, Frosty’s is a great place to gather, socialize, and enjoy the island atmosphere.
252 Delaware Ave Put-in-Bay , OH 43456 United States
| Reservations | No |
| Outdoor Seating | Yes |
| Menus | Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner |
| Drinks | Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails |
So delicious pizza and Beer !! i love it .This place to see before you die.
Great Biquits and Gravy
Best breakfast on the island . Grab a mimosa or bloody mary in relief of Friday night's frivolity or to pregame for the Buckeyes !
Go get your breakfast from the burrito bar they have tater tots !
Good Bloody Mary . Wish you could get breakfast at the bar though.
Don't bump your head here. Might get Life Flighted. :)
Ask for the Frosty-O
The back of the bar is sweet. My favorite put in bay bar
The new back patio & taco bar make a classic PIB bar even better. Read more
A little overpriced for what you get in quality & size but the BBQ Chicken Pizza wasn't bad.
One of the best free bathrooms after a night race.
This Buffalo chicken is great!
frosty mug , awesome pizza !
Fast wifi !
Good coffee & breakfast in the a.m.
Pizza , yo!
Service was terrible ... Not quite sure how you mess up breakfast but they did ... Overcooked and burnt food ... And no food to go (really?)
Really only for adults, don't bring kids here. Chicken Patio next door is great to eat. - Annamaria Settanni McDonald Artist
Awesome bacon cheeseburger and fries. Great atmosphere and a lot of fun! A definite must when visiting the island! - Barb Hess