Burger of the week was very juicy, fresh, and flavorful. The free ice cream at the end of the meal was a nice touch. The ice cream is available to purchase by the quart as well .

My favourite sandwich is the Reuben - a must! With each order of sandwich , you get a sampler of their amazing frozen custard ; just three flavours: vanilla , chocolate , and the flavour of the day!

This isn't ice cream - it's custard , and it's amazing! A full food and coffee menu is available, but ask anybody who's visited Cumberland and they'll know the "ice cream " served at the Creamery!

The sandwiches are very good and big enough to be shareable, particularly to save room for the complimentary small ice cream cone . My 89 yo father-in-law loved this place as did we.

Awesome food! Love trying the flavors of the day whenever I can, but my favorite is Death by Chocolate !

I've only had the ice cream here - actually it's custard - and it's delicious!! Worth the stop and cost to try the custard .

Panini of the week is almost always delicious, and the ice cream/milkshakes are incredible

Nice people, good service , great ice cream . The sandwiches are meats and vegetables on a wrap . Extremely plain and not tasty. Soups are just cans heated up, unfortunately.

The chocolate malts are so good that I almost have one a day when I'm in town !

I thought with "Creamery" in their name they'd have a plethora of flavors but they only have vanilla , chocolate and their flavor of the day. Oh and they serve custard not ice cream .

Very good sandwiches and ice cream . They always have a new daily flavor and they are usually very tasty :)

Get the Reuben ... seriously... And the Ham and Bean soup , if available! The cornbread with it ROCKS!

Strawberry milkshake is a delight the bottom of the cup is full of them

The homemade waffle cones are heavenly! They have a root beer float bar !

Good service , great ice cream and soups . Expensive but good. Sandwiches/wraps are so-so.

The flavor of the day is almost always great! Today it's German chocolate cake . Bought some. Delishhhh.

Underrated coffee and the ice cream is excellent.

You can't beat a Reuben and a malt !

They give you a little cone while you wait for your food - can it get any better?!?

When winter comes around, grab a free travel cup or ice scraper!

Love this place, but paying $10 for a chicken salad sandwich is nuts !

This place used to be great a few years back. Now the portions are small, prices outrageous, and staff is very rude. Unfortunately, despite having been here a lot, I won't be returning.

The ice cream is life changing existence. Better than church

Raved to a friend about how amazing this place was. And it used to be. Paid 10$ for three milkshakes that were all really thin and super bland. Yuck! You have one more chance!

While the food might be alright, the custards and ice creams are amazing!!

The best ice cream in the quad state region!!

Pina colada is gudddd!

No ice cream here at all...just custard . If you're craving ice cream , don't come here, cause there's none.

Try some pumpkin soup on Thursdays

Pineapple sorbet was amazing.

Try the chocolate-, nut-covered waffle cone

Come here to eat instead of braving the walking dead at Mcdonalds.

Just paid $10 for a turkey wrap . How is this place still in business!?

Sandwiches are overpriced and average