You will not find a better sandwich anywhere! Generous and delicious! Vegan if you wish. Great specials: panninis and soup . Build your own, too! Love, love, love SeaStar! Just go here!

Don't worry about that long line . The food is worth it and the service is pretty quick. Loved the honey mustard in that Bistro and the oatmeal cookie was tasty. Everything was so fresh!

Tabbouleh wrap was HUGE and excellent. Hummus tasted homemade . Nice little outdoor seating area by marsh. Good coffee . And they DO take cards now. I'd def recommend for lunch when you're on the island

Absolutely delicious sandwiches - plenty of veggie and vegan options , delicious flavoured UNSWEETENED(!) iced teas .

Most everything is good, really. I've yet to have a bad experience. Food is always fresh and delicious.

This place makes delicious sandwiches with an artisan 's flair. This is a must stop place when we swing by Chincoteague.

A great place to eat, but expect it to take a while if it's busy. You might want to bring your own water to drink while waiting in line on a hot day.

Absolutely delicious lunch and super nice service, but service was also quite slow (40 min from arrival until food was ready...)

Great veggie selection ! I recommend the Zorba Pita , tasted super fresh!

Some of the best food on the island . Try the mushroom bisque!

When you pick up your food, walk behind Don's over to the waterfront to eat your meal.

This place has long lines but the food is worth the wait.

Very yummy sandwiches . Casual and quick service .

I always get the Virginian. Best sandwiches on the island .

Hi guys ! Will definitely try these delicious dish. Are you following an interesting page on foursquare, called ShoutaBRAND.com ? Read more

Wow! Wait until you see the new Sea Star!

Remember to bring cash since they don't take cards. Awesome food!

Chicken salad sandwich and a lemonade . Amazing.

Try the Aristocrat--its delish! (Any sandwich with Brie is special)

Food was good, just not for the prices they charge. 9 dollars for a wrap is a little high

Try the black bean soup . It's delicious :)

Try anything with their homemade hummus !

If not for this place I might starve here!

Good but needs to calm down on prices. $1.75 for bag of chips ? Wtf